Books-turned-movies which s-u-c-k


Blogcritics.org has the lament.

My vote? The Chocolate War.


TrackBacks: 1

Posted by , Thursday, June 26, 2003, at 9:00 PM.
Posted to Books

Comments:

Is it bad to say, “All of them?”

Giles Hoover , June 26, 2003 10:11 PM (#)

Amanda, that’s pretty strong language for you!

Karen , June 27, 2003 9:38 AM (#)

You’re right. I should be more careful.

Books-turned-movies which are lousy seems less powerful though.

BTW, should it be which are lousy or that are lousy?

Amanda , June 27, 2003 10:50 AM (#)

Per the Columbia Guide to Standard English (which I love), it should be “Books-turned-movies that are lousy.”

Best advice: use that or which or nothing, depending on what your ear tells you. Then, when writing for certain publications, know that you may have to replace a good many whiches with thats, and perhaps a that or two with a which, to conform to the “rule” almost no one follows perfectly in other than Edited English and few can follow perfectly even there.
Rachel , June 27, 2003 11:23 AM (#)

Rachel! Thank you so much!

Amanda , June 27, 2003 12:01 PM (#)

Giles is correct… I don’t think any book I have read was ever upstaged by the movie. Just the opposite.
Is “lousy” still considered slang?

Cheryl , June 29, 2003 11:55 AM (#)

There are a few that can be considered just as good or better, I think.

lousy

adj 1: very bad; “a lousy play”; “it’s a stinking world” [syn: icky, crappy, rotten, shitty, stinking, stinky] 2: infested with lice; “burned their lousy clothes” 3: vile; despicable; “a dirty (or lousy) trick”; “a filthy traitor” [syn: dirty, filthy]

I don’t think it’s slang. This is from the wonderful Dictionary.com

Sckiye , March 22, 2005 12:26 PM (#)

There are a few that can be considered just as good or better, I think.

lousy

adj 1: very bad; “a lousy play”; “it’s a stinking world” [syn: icky, crappy, rotten, shitty, stinking, stinky] 2: infested with lice; “burned their lousy clothes” 3: vile; despicable; “a dirty (or lousy) trick”; “a filthy traitor” [syn: dirty, filthy]

I don’t think it’s slang. This is from the wonderful Dictionary.com

Sckiye , March 22, 2005 12:26 PM (#)

hey..
people..are u discussing which adaptations were lousy or the word lousy itself?…please refrain from changing the topic..and discuss whats neccesary.

withheld , August 5, 2005 3:47 AM (#)

Add to the discussion.

Note: Foreword uses comment moderation to help combat spam. Sign in to receive "trusted commenter" status and have your comments approved immediately. Otherwise, until your comment is reviewed, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for your understanding.